Mahalo New York Bakery

Mahalo New York was created because I wanted to share with New York all of the exotic flavors I grew up with, and the flavors I tasted in Hawaii on my honeymoon. The many tastes and pure nature of Hawaii invoked the happiness in me. I found myself saying “Oh my god! It’s so pretty!” to almost everything I saw there. The flavors of Hawaii were mouth watering good! I was amazed of how similar the flavors of Hawaii were to the flavors I grew up with in Guyana. I wanted to bring some of those flavors to New York City. Together, my husband and I created a line of tropical and classic American treats that we both love eating ourselves. We use only the finest ingredients, and bake for our customers as if we are baking for our loved ones. We serve cupcakes, cakes, pastries, coffee, ice-cream and smiles. Baking and bringing your ideas to life is our goal!

Cupcakes, Cakes, & Pastries ($3.00 Individual/$16.50 per 6-pack/$33 per Standard Dozen) Vanilla (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) Vanilla cupcake with vanilla cream cheese frosting (color of frosting can be change). Chocolate A chocolate cake topped with chocolate cream cheese frosting. Red Velvet A red velvet cake topped with cream cheese frosting and white chocolate curls. Hibiscus A hibiscus and cardamom cupcake infused with a hibiscus and rose milk syrup and topped with a hibiscus flavored whipped cream. Mango Mango Mango cupcake infused with mango puree, topped with mango cream cheese frosting. Milk Lovers A vanilla cake, infused with a concoction of milks with our signature twist of cardamom spice, and topped with whipped cream. Vanilla Raspberry (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A vanilla cake filled with raspberry jam, topped with raspberry cream cheese frosting, finished with dash of white chocolate curls. Chocolate Raspberry (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A chocolate cake filled with raspberry, topped with raspberry cream cheese frosting, finished with a light dash of chocolate chocolate curls. Banana Hazelnut (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A banana cupcake topped with hazelnut butter cream frosting. Toasted Coconut A coconut cupcake, frost with coconut cream cheese frosting and topped with toasted coconut flakes. Coco Pineapple Twist A flavorful coconut cake topped with a ring of coconut cream cheese frosting and pineapple jam. Pineapple Guava A moist vanilla cake that is filled with guava jam. It is top with a ring of cream cheese frosting and chunky pineapple jam. A bit of this cupcake is like a bit of tropical paradise. Cookies and Cream A moist chocolate cake topped with cookies and cream frosting. Strawberry Shortcake (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A moist vanilla cupcake, filled with strawberry compote, topped with whipped cream Taro Coconut (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A moist coconut cake. Infused with Taro milk. Topped with Taro buttercream frosting and crushed toasted coconut Apple Strudel (Fall flavor) A flavorful sponge cake bake with apple chunks. Topped with a cinnamon buttercream frosting and apple compote Chocolate Hazel (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) Chocolate Cake, chocolate hazelnut filling, topped with a ring of hazelnut buttercream Chocolate Chip (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) A vanilla cake bake with chocolate chips, frost with chocolate frosting. VEGAN Cupcakes ($3.50 Individual/$37.80 per Dozen) Honey (agave) Bunny Moist carrot cupcake made with fresh carrots, raisins, and spices such as nutmeg, cloves and cinnamon topped with an agave frosting and chopped walnuts Matcha Cupcake with Blueberry Frosting (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) Moist Matcha based cupcake with a blueberry frosting and filled with a blueberry compote Cakes (All cakes are made to order, three days notice needed for a standard cake. At least three weeks to two months notice depending on availability for themed cakes, fondant decorated cake or tiered cakes) Please email or call to book an appointment and confirm availability. Please email us at with image attached (if possible) for a quote. $20 Standard 5″ Cakes(reflecting cupcakes &feeds 7 people) $35 Standard 7″ Cakes(reflecting cupcakes & feeds 15 people) $50 Standard 9″ Cakes(reflecting cupcakes & feeds 30 people) $90 Standard 11″ Cakes(reflecting cupcakes & feeds 40 people) Custom Orders We pride ourselves on tailoring your cake order to your exact needs – please call us or email us for pricing Visit our gallery section to see examples of past orders Mini Desserts (Flavors will vary, please call to confirm availability) $5 Mango/Passion Fruit Whipped Cheesecake A delicious and light twist of mango and passion fruit cheesecake which sits on top of a cinnamon and spiced graham crumb. The cheesecake is then top with a thin layer of guava jam, and garnish with fresh mango and kiwi. $5 Haupia Pie Layers of semi-sweet (60.3%) Belgium Chocolate, traditional Haupia (coconut based), coconut whipped cream and topped with flakes of toasted coconut and chocolate. $5 (By Special Order Only – six minimum) Flourless Chocolate A dense and rich cake consists of Semi Sweet (60.3%) Belgium Chocolate, topped with powdered sugar. $5 Chocolate Hazelnut Mousse A classic airy texture chocolaty hazelnut mousse that is layered with chocolate cake. Top with chocolate shavings. $5 Mocha Delight This is a moist chocolate cake that is soaked in coffee syrup, and then layered with espresso mousse. Finished with a dash of cocoa powder. $1.75 Cake Balls Crushed chocolate cake that is blended with caramel and hazelnut spread. The mixture is rolled into a bite size ball then dipped in dark chocolate. $2.75 Nutella Brownies & Coconut Brownies $2.75 (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) Cake Pops Crushed moist cake rolled in pop shape. Dipped and decorated with white chocolate $2.50 (By Special Order Only – dozen minimum) Chocolate Cover Sandwich Cookies Oreo cookie dipped in white chocolate and decorated Pies Passion Fruit, Orange, Guava) Crumble A delicious combination of Passion Fruit, Orange and Guava custard baked in a flaky pie crust topped with a cinnamon crumble Pecan Traditional pie crust baked with chopped pecans, spices and brown sugar. It has a caramel bottom with a nutty top. Coconut Cream A combination of coconut and silky egg custard filling baked golden in a traditional pie crust. Topped with toasted shredded coconut Pumpkin A perfectly balance combination of sugar, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and pumpkin baked to a creamy perfection.

Myrtle Avenue 66-40
11385 NY US
Get directions

Is this your business?Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date.