Magnolia Bakery

Classic Cupcakes $3.95 ea Specialty Cupcakes $3.95 ea Pies Mini Pie 12.00 • 9’’ Pie 34.00 Flourless Chocolate Breakfast Icebox Pies & Bars Blueberry Jamboree pecan shortbread crust layered with whipped cream and cream cheese filling with a fresh blueberry topping Key Lime our handmade graham cracker crust with traditional key lime custard filling Peanut Butter vanilla wafer crust layered with a caramel and a peanut butter whipped cream and cream cheese filling, topped with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Snickers chocolate wafer crust layered with peanut butter, cream cheese, and whipped cream filling, topped with Snickers Bar pieces Chocolate Pudding Pie Mini Pie $8.00 9’’ Pie $24.00 graham cracker crust with homemade chocolate pudding topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate shavings *Available as pie only Banana Cream Pie vanilla wafer crust layered with fresh bananas and vanilla pudding, topped with fresh whipped cream *Available as pie only Chocolate Pudding Parfait $6.00 layered with pieces of chocolate cake, fresh whipped cream, topped with chocolate shavings Advance Order Menu We bake everything from scratch on the premises every day using the fnest ingredients. Ask us about what special items we’re offering this month! Confetti vanilla cake with confetti sprinkles inside topped with chocolate or vanilla buttercream Banana caramel filling with caramel meringue buttercream – also available with chocolate buttercream (no filling) Black & White chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream and whipped vanilla icing Caramel caramel meringue buttercream with a caramel drizzle Carrot cream cheese icing topped with walnuts Coconut meringue icing topped with shredded coconut Devil’s Food your choice of mocha, cream cheese, chocolate buttercream or caramel cream cheese icing German Chocolate coconut caramel pecan topping Hummingbird banana, pineapple and pecan cake with sweet cream cheese icing topped with toasted pecans Lemon delicate lemon cake filled with tart lemon cream and topped with lemon meringue buttercream Peanut Butter & Jelly peanut butter cake with jelly filling and peanut butter buttercream Truffle devil’s food cake with chocolate or white chocolate truffle filling covered with chocolate ganache A selection of specialty cupcakes are offered daily. For advance orders a minimum of 1 dozen per flavor is required. See our calendar for weekly specials. Slice $6.00 3 layer 6’’ $40.00 / Decorated Starting at $50.00* 2-layer 9’’ $50.00 / Decorated Starting at $65.00* 3-layer 9’’ $65.00 / Decorated Starting at $80.00* Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake Slice $4.00 • 9” Cake $35 Whole Cakes & Cake Slices Apple piled high with apples and a touch of cinnamon Apple Crumb apple filling with a crumbly sweet topping Pecan or Black Bottom Pecan southern classics ‘Nolia Pies $10 our buttery crust filled with seasonal fruits, including apple, peach, blueberry and more Fruit Crisps $4.75 fresh blueberry or apple filling with a crumb topping *OREO is a registered trademark of Mondeléz International group. While we do have select products that do not contain wheat or nuts, all of our products are baked in an environment where wheat, dairy and nuts are present in high volumes. Due to the presence of these allergens at all of our baking facilities, we do not recommend consuming any of our desserts if you are allergic to wheat, nuts or dairy. Vanilla rich, buttery, old-fashioned cake with a light crumb. Our most popular cupcake! Chocolate rich moist cake with a smooth velvety texture and dark chocolate flavor Minis 20.00 a dozen of our favorite assorted classics Red Velvet whipped vanilla icing – also available with cream cheese icing Flower $5.75 ea a buttercream flower in your choice of color (a minimum of 1 dozen per order) Edible Image $5.50 ea your photograph printed on edible paper Available with chocolate or vanilla buttercream in your choice of Magnolia Bakery’s own pastel colors and hand-colored sprinkles. Add .50 for inscribed cupcakes. Custom decorations available. Scones 3.75 ea Apple Cinnamon Blueberry Lemon Cherry Chocolate Almond Cranberry Pecan Lemon Poppy Seed Maple Pecan Muffins 3.50 ea Apple Walnut & Cranberry Banana Blueberry Crumb Cappuccino Chocolate Chip Cinnamon Sugar Lemon Zest Poppy Seed with Lemon Glaze Raisin Bran Pumpkin A minimum of 1/2 dozen muffins per type is required for advance orders. Mini muffins available at $1.50 ea, minimum order of 1 dozen. Loaves Whole $34 • Slice $3.50 Apple Harvest Carrot Hummingbird Pumpkin Banana Classic Icebox Cake Mini $6.00 • Small (4-8) $24.00 • Large (6-10) $38.00 • Slice $7.00 Homemade chocolate wafers layered with freshly whipped sweet cream. Also available in strawberry or peppermint. Icebox Desserts Brownies & Bars Chocolate Chunk Blondie Double Fudge Brownie Lemon Bar Peanut Butter Oatmeal Raisin 3.50 ea. Mini Cheesecakes 7.95 ea (with seasonal fruit topping: 8.95 ea) Smooth and velvety, old-fashioned style, individually portioned cheesecake on a cookie crumb crust. Classic Cheesecakes Caramel Pecan • Key Lime • Vanilla Bean • Red Velvet Speciality Cheesecakes Chocolate • Lemon • German Chocolate • Peanut Butter & Chocolate Pistachio • Vanilla & Chocolate Swirl Magnolia Bakery’s Famous Banana Pudding Classic: Layers of vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and creamy vanilla pudding Chocolate: Layers of OREO® wafers, fresh bananas, creamy chocolate pudding, and chocolate shavings Small $4.50 • Medium $6.25 • Large $7.50 Small Bowl $38.00 (serves 8) • Medium Bowl $45.00 (serves 10) • Large Bowl $75.00 (serves 20) Ask about our monthly favor! Confetti vanilla cake with confetti sprinkles inside with chocolate or vanilla buttercream Banana moist banana cake with chocolate or caramel meringue buttercream Caramel rich, buttery cake with caramel meringue buttercream and a caramel drizzle Carrot freshly grated carrots, coconut, pineapple, raisins and walnuts with cream cheese icing Coconut coconut cake with a sweet coconut filling and meringue icing sprinkled with shredded coconut Devil’s Food made with Dutch cocoa. Your choice of chocolate, caramel or mocha buttercream, or caramel cream cheese icing German Chocolate rich, sweet chocolate cake layered with coconut caramel pecan filling Hummingbird banana, pineapple and pecans make up this classic southern cake with sweet cream cheese icing Lemon delicate lemon cake filled with tart lemon cream and topped with lemon meringue buttercream LOCAL PICKUP NATIONWIDE SHIPPING WEDDINGS & SPECIAL EVENTS @magnoliabakery B Flourless Chocolate Cake dense, rich fudgy chocolate cake Mini cake $4.00 1-Layer 9’’ cake $40.00 +$10.00 w/ vanilla meringue buttercream 2-Layer with vanilla meringue buttercream $80.00 Flourless Chocolate Cupcakes 4.00 ea dense, rich fudgy chocolate cake made without flour with vanilla bean meringue buttercream or your choice of icing

Cookies Classic $1.75 ea Cracked Sugar Brown Sugar Chocolate Chunk Classic Coconut Macaroon $2.00 ea plain and chocolate dipped Sea Salt Caramel Cookie $3.50 a chocolate chunk cookie topped with sea salt and homemade caramel candy Confetti $3.50 a large classic sugar cookie with confetti folded into the dough. Reese’s Pieces® $3.50 a peanut butter cookie with Reese’s Pieces® Black and White $3.50

Columbus Avenue 200
New York 10023 NY US
Get directions

Is this your business?Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date.