6 Fun and Delicious Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Combos

6 Fun and Delicious Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Combos

Ice cream cookie sandwiches are the perfect treat for cooling down on a hot afternoon or just as a fun dessert before bedtime. This dessert takes two of some of our most favorite sweets and pairs them together to create a creamy, soft, decadently chewy frozen treat.

It’s said that the ice cream sandwich came to be in the sweltering summer of 1899 when a pushcart salesman in New York City began making these delights by hand with vanilla ice cream and chocolate wafer cookies, and they became so much of a hit that other ice cream vendors started making them that summer as well to keep up with demands.

Nowadays, you can find these wonderful frozen treats with vanilla wafer cookies, chocolate chip cookies, cookies with candy pieces in them and so many more; of course the ice cream of choice is usually vanilla, but combinations such as Neapolitan ice cream and vanilla wafer cookie sandwiches are a thing as well. However, even though the store bought ones are pretty amazing, you can make your own at home with your choice of combinations of so many different kinds of cookies with just as many different varieties of ice cream and come up with fun, new flavors so they’re never boring! So why don’t you come and join us as we check out some of our choices for some fun and delicious ice cream cookie sandwich combinations, plus our bonus entry for a cool place to get a custom ice cream sandwich!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream Sandwich

Right out of the gates we’re going to start with a unique approach to the ice cream cookie sandwich. Now, most of us bake our cookies or the cookies on our assembled ice cream sandwiches are already baked, but with this fun idea, you can combine the decadence of rich, gooey cookie dough and your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or even cookie dough ice cream. As a disclaimer, many health officials advise against consuming raw cookie dough, but if you feel like living on the edge, then this is a fun treat for you to try!

Double Cookie Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

So you’re trying to choose between America’s favorite cookie, Oreos, or good old fashioned chocolate chip cookies for your ice cream sandwich. Well, what if we told you that you don’t have to choose? Ice creams such as cookie dough, Moose Tracks, or even just plain old vanilla make up the middle with the Oreo cookies sandwiching it in, then add a chocolate chip cookie onto the top and bottom and you’ve got yourself a double cookie ice cream cookie sandwich!


Oatmeal Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

When you think of oatmeal cookies, unless you’re a huge fan they’re not exactly the first kind of cookie you think of admittedly. However, using oatmeal cookies along with ice cream flavors like pistachio make a fun, tasty combo that not many would really think about.

Snickerdoodle and Fudge Ripple Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Just about everyone loved snickerdoodle cookies as a child, and this ice cream cookie sandwich recipe takes that classic favorite cookie and sandwiches fudge ripple ice cream in between two of them to create a fun, delicious combination that you won’t soon forget.

Peppermint Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

If you like peppermint, then this is an ice cream cookie sandwich combo you need to give a go! You can either buy peppermint ice cream for the occasion or make your own with vanilla ice cream and crushed peppermints or candy canes; this ice cream flavor pairs well with chocolate or vanilla cookies and would make an awesome dessert for the holiday season.

Reese’s Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

This one is for the peanut butter and Reese’s fans! Sandwich a Reese’s ice cream in between two peanut butter cookies and you’ve got a creamy, chewy dessert that packs in the peanut butter and Reese’s punch that you’re looking for! If you want to add even more depth to this recipe, if you’re baking the peanut butter cookies, add some Reese’s Pieces candy to the cookie dough.

The Baked Bear Custom Ice Cream Sandwiches

If you’re out and about in the states of Alabama, Arizona, California, Florida, Maryland, Missouri, New Jersey, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, or Texas, it’s quite likely that you’ve heard of The Baked Bear, but if you haven’t, you’re in for a real treat! The Baked Bear specializes in cookies, ice cream, and the beautiful marriage of the two to create ice cream cookie sandwiches. All of their cookies are homemade fresh every day from original recipe, and their ice cream is homemade as well with R-BGH-free cream, pure cane sugar, and all natural stabilizers.

The Baked Bear first opened in San Diego, California, when childhood friends Rob Robbins and Shane Stanger left their jobs to follow their true dream, which was coming up with fun, innovative sweets and sharing them with the people of San Diego. When they first opened the doors, they already had a line forming to get a taste of their custom ice cream sandwiches, and things haven’t changed much between now and then, even with expanding their locations.

At The Baked Bear, you can mix and match any of their cookies or brownies, like their Cookies & Cream, Gooey Butter Cake, or Sea Salt Peanut Butter Chocolate, and ice creams such as their Bear Batter, Blackberry Crumble, or Espresso bean to create the ultimate ice cream sandwich – and believe us, they don’t skimp on the ice cream! You end up with a huge ice cream sandwich stuffed with ice cream, and you can even choose toppings for your sandwich if you want to go extra! Believe us, this is one ice cream cookie sandwich experience you don’t want to miss out on. The best part? They offer nationwide shipping so even if you don’t live near a location, you can still try one or more of these cool creations!

With the warmer months not too far ahead of us now, we hope that these ideas for fun ice cream cookie sandwich combos and the creations from The Baked Bear inspire you to create some fun and delicious ice cream cookie sandwich combinations of your own!

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments